Review: Blue Lily, Lily Blue by Maggie Stiefvater

I am really burning through The Raven Cycle series by Maggie Stiefvater! I’ve already downloaded The Raven King and as soon as I finish listening to Nevernight by Jay Kristoff I’ll be getting stuck into the series finale.

If you haven’t read the first two books in the series, you can check out my no spoiler reviews here: The Raven Boys and The Dream Thieves.

TL;DR Gansey is still looking for Glendower, Adam is still proud, Ronan is still angry, and Blue is still independent. Maura is missing, the Grey Man is back and his boss, Greenmantle, is on the hunt for the Greywarren (now aware that it is a who and not a what).

Blue Lily, Lily Blue Maggie Stiefvater Lyndsey's Book Blog

4.5 stars

Synopsis

At the end of The Dream Thieves, Maura left a note for Blue to say she was going looking for Artemus – Blue’s father, who disappeared while Maura was pregnant and hasn’t been seen since. Now Maura is missing too, underground in the caves beneath Cabeswater.

Persephone is still helping Adam to master his powers and strengthen the ley line. His bargain with Cabeswater is effecting him more and more, making him darker and moodier, although he has learnt how to interpret its attempts at communication, which are often terrifying manifestations and visions.

“For so long, he’d wanted Gansey to see him as an equal, but it was possible that all this time, the only person who needed to see that was Adam.”

Ronan is still trying to figure out a way to save his mother, and all the other dream things that fell to sleep when his father died. He’s getting closer, his mother is now living in Cabeswater, where she seems to function again. Unfortunately, his dreams are encroaching more and more on his daily life, forcing him to sleep in his car rather than endanger Gansey by dreaming up a hornets’ nest inside Monmouth.

“Ronan was angry-every one of his emotions that wasn’t happiness was anger.”

Ronan and Adam spend a lot more time together in this book, working together on secret plans and using their connections to Cabeswater to try and fix the problems that the gang are battling – namely Greenmantle and his obsession with the Greywarren.

“They regarded each other. Adam fair and cautious, Ronan dark and incendiary. This was Ronan at his most truthful.”

Blue and Gansey’s relationship develops really nicely in this book, they continue to grow closer despite the obvious barriers – the fact that Gansey will die within twelve months and Blue will kill her true love if she kisses him. So, small, surmountable obstacles then.

“Blue was perfectly aware that it was possible to have a friendship that wasn’t all-encompassing, that wasn’t blinding, deafening, maddening, quickening. It was just that now that she’d had this kind, she didn’t want the other.”

Colin Greenmantle and his wife, Piper, are absolutely brilliant villains – funny, snarky and completely immoral. Colin replaces the baddie from book one, Barrington Whelk, as the boys’ Latin teacher at Aglionby, which leads to some hilarious exchanges between Colin and Ronan in Latin. Piper is a fabulously self-serving, sharp-tongued, blonde bombshell with a seriously dysfunctional moral compass. Their relationship is just fascinating, I don’t think I’ve ever loved a couple of villains as much as the Greenmantles.

“She drifted towards the bedroom, on her way to have a bath or take a nap or start a war.”

The other star of this book is Jesse Dittley, a man who’s family farmhouse sits on top of a cave they suspect Glendower might be buried in. As it turns out, the caves are cursed and eventually kill every member of Dittley’s family, including his father and grandfather. He finds Blue’s short stature fascinating and seems to be permanently shouting.

“I AM JESSE DITTLEY. DID YOU NEVER EAT YOUR GREENS?”

We also get to know Malory, Gansey’s British friend, much more in this book. He travels over to Henrietta, accompanied by his emotional support dog, and helps the gang find the caves where the believe Glendower to be hidden.

“Malory, unhopeful: “I don’t suppose you have any tea?”

Jesse: “DO YOU WANT EARL GREY OR DARJEELING?”

Malory: “Oh, sweet heavens!””

Blue Lily Lily Blue by Maggie Stiefvater review Lyndsey's Book Blog

I listened to Blue Lily, Lily Blue in two days (I was doing a lot of decorating and gardening due to us moving house next month) and I enjoyed it slightly more than The Dream Thieves. There are a couple of songs in this book, one being the moody and traditional Blue Lily, Lily Blue, the other being the catchy and annoying Murder Squash. I love the layers of art in these books, Maggie Stiefvater is a musician as well as a writer and always creates music for her books – one of the treats of listening to the audio books is not only hearing these songs aloud, but hearing Maggie playing her own music at the beginning and end of each book.

pink divider

One of my favourite things about The Raven Cycle is the slow development of romantic relationships. The obvious one is Blue and Gansey, who aren’t able to be together because of the aforementioned curses, but also because they don’t want to hurt Adam, who liked Blue first. In this book we finally start to see some hint of romance between Ronan and Adam (that might be a spoiler if you know literally nothing about The Raven Cycle, but if you spend any time at all online – especially Tumblr – then you’ll already know, as I did, that they get together).

It’s been hinted at very subtly throughout the series that Ronan is gay – by subtly, I mean it’s not openly stated and he isn’t constantly eyeing up guys, it is suggested that he feels something stronger than friendship for Gansey in the beginning, but that feeling is obviously not reciprocated. It isn’t at any point (that I noticed) suggested that Adam is gay, or bisexual, until this book, so I’m really looking forward to seeing how their relationship develops in The Raven King.

pink divider

I gave Blue Lily, Lily Blue 4.5 stars, because it was a more gripping read than The Dream Thieves and had less elements I wasn’t a fan of – if anything, the only thing I didn’t love was Malory, I’m not sure his presence really added anything to the story. The tension and suspense is still present in this book, and I am dying to seeing how it all pans out in the final book.

Have you read The Raven Cycle? Which of the four books was your favourite? I’ve seen online that a lot of readers weren’t happy with the finale so I’m slightly apprehensive, but I really need to see what happens to these characters now, I’m so invested!

 

Lyndsey

x

I am a member of the Book Depository affiliate program, so if you click through and buy any of the books mentioned in this blog I might make a little commission, but I am not paid to review books and all reviews are my own opinions!

Review Blue Lily, Lily Blue by Maggie Stiefvater Lyndsey's Book Blog

Writing an epilogue

If you haven’t read my post on writing prologues you might want to pop over and give that a read – you can even read the original version of my prologue for The Fair Queen from my very first draft!

Epilogues, like prologues, are a hotly debated topic amongst writers. Some love them, some hate them. But they can add an additional layer to your work, when used correctly.

Let’s have a look at how to, and how not to, write an epilogue.

Writing epilogues Lyndsey's Book Blog

As I’m sure you’ve worked out by now, I’ve used a prologue and an epilogue in my current work-in-progress. If you read my post about writing your story’s ending, you might recognise the circular ending tradition. This is where your story ends in the same place as it begins, or the ending brings in elements that are reminiscent of your beginning.

I’ve used an epilogue to bring my story full circle in the sense that it is framed by a prologue and epilogue, each with a time jump (eighteen years earlier in the prologue, three months later in the epilogue). Elements from both the prologue and chapter one reappear in the epilogue to really tie it into the story.

I’ve always hoped to turn The Fair Queen into a series, with at least two, maybe three books. However, in my research into querying agents and publishers, I discovered that debut authors rarely get series offers, so it’s best to wrap your story up at the end in a way that will satisfy readers if there’s no sequel, but express to the agent/publisher that it could extend into a series.

With that in mind…

divider-grey

Dos and don’t of writing an epic epilogue:

Don’t

  • use an epilogue to tie up loose ends that should have been tied off in your story’s climax and following scenes
  • tack on a lot of unnecessary information that your reader won’t care about, if it doesn’t add anything to the story, cut it
  • leave your readers with more questions than you answer, you should be concluding the story rather than setting up a sequel (a few hints are fine if a sequel is definitely forthcoming)

Do

  • skip forward in time if appropriate, revealing the outcomes of events at the end of the story further into the future
  • write your epilogue from another character’s POV if your MC dies in the story’s conclusion, or if you intend to write a sequel from this other character’s POV
  • explain the outcomes for any much loved secondary characters who may not have been involved in the final scenes of the story’s climax

divider-grey

Your epilogue shouldn’t be dead weight dragging the ending of your novel down. Sometimes an exciting, action-filled climax requires a steady finish to give a satisfying end, but other times your story is best left off after the main action concludes. This is something your Critique Partners and Beta Readers can help you with, if they see the epilogue as unnecessary then it should probably be cut. If you absolutely love it leave it in, but be prepared for an editor to tell you to cut it later.

So there you have it, a few basic tips on whether your story needs an epilogue and how to make sure it serves your story and doesn’t end up getting cut later.

What are your thoughts on epilogues? Do you skip them? Love them? Do you have any advice on writing them? Leave me your tips in the comments!

 

Lyndsey

x

Writing an epilogue Lyndsey's Book Blog

The new Disney Princess book tag

Thank you to Shanya and Tanya @ TwinBookmarks for tagging me to do the new Disney Princess book tag, this is such a fun one! There are 13 questions, so grab a cup of tea and a blanket and settle in, it’s going to be a long one.

New Disney princess tag Lyndsey's Book Blog

THE RULES
  • Mention where you saw the tag/thank whoever tagged you because that’s always good fun
  • Tag Mandy @ Book Princess Reviews and Zuky @ BookBum so they can check out the wonderful Princess fun throughout the blog world
  • Play a game of tag at the end!

pink divider

Snow White – This book (like the movie) started it all

Favourite debut book from an author

Half Bad by Sally Green Lyndsey's Book Blog

Half Bad by Sally Green

I was given Half Bad by a friend who works at Waterstones, I’d never heard of it but it was a new release at the time and he thought I’d like it. Well, he was right, I am absolutely obsessed with this series, and I feel like not enough people have read it or talk about it. I’m yet to read the third in the trilogy, but it’s right at the top of my list!

Sally Green is currently working on a new book called The Smoke Thieves, which comes out next spring and sounds amazing!

pink divider

Cinderella – A diamond in the rough

Just like Cinderella, you didn’t expect much out of this character in the beginning, but they turned out to be a total gem

A Court of Wings and Ruin Sarah J Maas Lyndsey's Book Blog

Nesta from the A Court of Thorns and Roses series by Sarah J. Maas

I really did not like Nesta in A Court of Thorns and Roses, she was so mean and spoilt, and treated Feyre like dirt. But, by the end of A Court of Wings and Ruin I actually loved her, she turned out to be brave and loyal, and one of the strongest female characters I’ve ever come across.

pink divider

Aurora – Sleeping Beauty

A book that makes you sleepy or could not hold your attention

The Shadow Queen by C J Redwine Lyndsey's Book Blog

The Shadow Queen by C.J. Redwine

I really want to like this book, it’s exactly my usual sort of thing – fairytale retelling, YA, high fantasy – but I’m struggling to get into it. It’s very dense with new names, places and creatures and I think I’m just not in the mood, because I’d normally be obsessed, but I’m just finding it so easy to put down and walk away from. I’m going to persevere because I’ve heard good things and I want to love it. It’s not boring, or badly written, it’s just not pulling me in.

pink divider

Ariel – Under the sea

A book with a water/ocean setting

Nevernight Jay Kristoff Lyndsey's Book Blog

Nevernight by Jay Kristoff

I’m listening to the audio book of this at the moment, and absolutely loving it. Mia just sailed from one continent to another on a boat, so I think this counts as a water based book. It was this or Crooked Kingdom by Leigh Bardugo – I don’t read many books set at sea and this needs to change. Give me your pirate book recs!

pink divider

Belle – Beauty and the books

Name a book with the best bookworm/book lover

Throne of Glass by Sarah J Maas Lyndsey's Book Blog

Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas

I can’t choose between Celaena and Dorian, they bond over their shared love of books (and dogs!) and are just adorable book dragons. If you ignore the fact she’s an assassin and a slave (I won’t say anymore, no spoilers!) Celaena is totally relatable – she loves books, clothes, shopping and the opera.

pink divider

Jasmine – The thief and the princess

Name a book with an unlikely love story (either in terms of romance or a book you didn’t expect to love so much)

Anna Dressed in Blood Kendare Blake Lyndsey's Book Blog

Anna Dressed in Blood by Kendare Blake

Boy hunts ghosts. Finds scariest ghost ever. Falls in love.

If you haven’t read Anna Dressed in Blood, what are you doing? Go and read it now! It’s a hilarious, cute, terrifying YA horror – Cas is like the younger Winchester brother you wish Sam and Dean had.

pink divider

Pocahontas – The real life princess

Name a book that is based on a real life person you want to read/have read

Talking as Fast as I Can Lauren Graham Lyndsey's Book Blog

Talking as fast as I can by Lauren Graham

I’m not normally a biography or autobiography reader, I like fiction, fantasy worlds, magic etc. But if there was one autobiography I was going to read it would be Lauren Graham’s. I’ve heard she actually reads the audio book herself, so I’m probably going to get that at some point. I just think she’s hilarious, and Gilmore Girls is one of my all time favourite shows, so I’d love to hear all her stories from behind the scenes.

Other potentials include Amy Schumer, Anna Kendrick and Amy Poehler.

pink divider

Mulan – The princess that saved her country

Name the fiercest heroine you know

The Scorpio Races Maggie Stiefvater Lyndsey's Book Blog

Puck from The Scorpio Races by Maggie Stiefvater

Puck lost both her parents to a water horse attack, she lives with her two brothers who are sweet but ultimately useless, and she is facing eviction from the home she grew up in. Instead of falling to pieces, she decides to enter the most dangerous competition in existence, a horse race between the capaill uisce, only she decides to ride her regular old horse. Seriously, if she isn’t the fiercest, most badass heroine you’ve ever read then you haven’t read The Scorpio Races.

pink divider

Tiana – The princess with the coolest and most diverse crew

Name a diverse book, whether it is a diverse set of characters or just diverse in general

Six of Crows by Maggie Steifvater Lyndsey's Book Blog

Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo

Kaz, Inej, Jesper, Nina, Wylan and Matthias are the most diverse gang of thieves and crooks I’ve ever seen in literature. Seriously, check out some of the gorgeous fanart that’s been created with these characters. I love each and every one of these gun-toting, knife-wielding, bank-robbing beauts. Plus, it’s set in the same universe as the Grisha Trilogy, which gives it such a rich history and culture to build on. It’s one of the best series I’ve ever read.

pink divider

Rapunzel – Let your long hair down

Name the longest book you’ve ever read

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix J K Rowling Lyndsey's Book Blog

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix by J. K. Rowling

At a whopping 870 pages, Order of the Phoenix is the longest book I have ever read, and I don’t regret a single second of it. Other notably long books I’ve read are City of Heavenly Fire at 725 pages, and A Court of Wings and Ruin by Sarah J. Maas at 699.

(To find out the longest book you’ve read you can go to My Books on your Goodreads, find Stats on the left, and check the pages tab for each year you’ve been a member. You’re welcome!)

pink divider

Merida – I determine my own fate

A book where there is no love story/interest 

The Queen of the Tearling Erike Johansen

The Queen of the Tearling by Erika Johansen

I love Kelsea’s character arc from The Queen of the Tearling, she’s such a layered character with so many strengths and weaknesses, and she becomes a great queen without any need for a king or a boyfriend. She does have a brief fling with one of her guards, but she ends it when she realises he feels more strongly about her than she does about him. The whole story is about female empowerment, as much as it’s about a fantasy dystopian future.

pink divider

Anna & Elsa – Frozen hearts

A book in a winter/cold setting

Black Ice Becka Fitzpatrick Lyndsey's Book Blog

Black Ice by Becca Fitzpatrick

Unfortunately I DNFed this one because it was a library book and my loan ran out, but I might come back to it at some point. It’s a YA thriller, which there aren’t enough of, about a girl who goes hiking in the snowy mountains and gets kidnapped and held hostage by a couple of guys in a log cabin.

pink divider

Moana – How far I’ll go

A character that goes on a journey

Kiss of Deception by Mary E Pearson Lyndsey's Book Blog

Kiss of Deception by Mary E. Pearson

In the first book of The Remnant Chronicles, Lia travels from her home to a remote coastal town to escape her duties as future queen. In the second book, she travels across the lands with a band of “barbarians” to their kingdom, stopping at various outposts along the way, and in the third book she travels back from the barbarian kingdom to her own. That’s a lot of travelling!

pink divider

Nominations

I’m just going to nominate a few people, if you’ve already done this tag or don’t fancy it, that’s OK! If I haven’t nominated you but you want to try, go ahead, and tag me so I can see your answers.

pink divider

Have you read any of these books? Do you have any recs for me? Give your thoughts and opinions people, I need to know if you love or hate The Shadow Queen, and if you have any pirate themed books I should read!

 

Lyndsey

x

 

The New Disney princesses book tag Lyndsey's Book Blog